Cloud seeding is a scientific process that improves a cloud’s ability to make rain or snow, as well as control other weather events. The technique, which experts also call weather modification, can really help in areas that don’t have a big enough supply of natural water. After cloud seeding, precipitation (rain or snow) will fall from the clouds onto the ground.
When Did Cloud Seeding Start?
This method started in 1946 by scientists at the General Electric Research Laboratory. They discovered that they could use silver iodide -- an inorganic compound -- and dry ice to improve the creation of ice crystals in clouds.
Today, cloud seeding still involves silver iodide and dry ice. But in the last 60 years, experts have learned a lot more about this method. This has since boosted the understanding of rain and snow processes and improved seeding methods.
How Does Cloud Seeding Work?
Not all clouds create rain. Even if they do make rainwater, only a few clouds are able to produce enough moisture that allows for large raindrops.
This may happen because there aren’t enough ice particles within a cloud. Because of this, there aren’t enough cloud droplets to combine and make raindrops. Another reason that certain rainclouds may struggle to make rain is that some don’t last long enough to have cloud droplets gather to create rain.
Cloud seeding gives these clouds a lot more ice crystals (or cloud nuclei). If experts complete seeding at the right time, it leads to more moisture supply, which will eventually create rainwater.
Experts use silver iodide because its structure is very similar to natural ice crystals. When they put silver iodide in the top part of a growing cloud, the silver iodide crystal grows quickly once exposed to the cloud’s moisture. Right after, the ice crystal becomes a heavy, large raindrop. It will then fall through the cloud and onto the ground. Just 1 gram of silver iodide can create up to 10 trillion artificial ice crystals.
Scientists have found two main ways to conduct cloud seeding:
Release silver iodide particles from below the cloud base. Pyrotechnics (or flares) on the wings of planes burn silver iodide from below the clouds. The updraft from the cloud takes the particles high into the center of the cloud.
Drop silver iodide particles from above the cloud. Planes can also let off electrical pyrotechnics over the top of clouds. The flares become ignited once they fall off the plane and onto the cloud.
Sometimes, silver iodide may not be the best option. In droughts, clouds may not be able to create cloud droplets with this approach. But the clouds still have a lot of water in them, it’s just in tiny droplets. If this is the case, a hygroscopic material (like regular salt) might be a better option to cloud seed with.
Experts may also use liquid propane, dry ice (solid carbon dioxide), and other salt compounds to “seed” clouds.
In 2021, the United Arab Emirates began to experiment with the use of aerial drones for cloud seeding. The new twist on the old concept uses drones to cast an electric charge. This “zaps” clouds with a laser beam, which causes water droplets to combine and leads to rainfall.
What Are the Benefits of Cloud Seeding?
Cloud seeding can help in many ways. It can:
- Create more winter snowfall and lead to more mountain snowpack
- Enhance the natural water supply to communities
- Lessen hailstorms by reordering water vapor in clouds, which breaks down large hailstones
Does Cloud Seeding Have an Impact on Health and the Environment?
So far, experts haven’t found any harmful effects of cloud seeding with silver iodide on the environment. The concentration of silver in a storm from cloud seeding is far below the accepted limit of 50 micrograms per liter. There is a lot more iodine in iodized salt (the salt that humans eat) than there is in this form of rainwater.
Even in projects that have lasted 30 to 40 years, researchers haven’t found any major concerns in cloud seeding processes.
Rainwater from seeding clouds doesn’t taste or smell any different than regular rainwater. You wouldn’t be able to tell the difference between the two.
While we don’t know specifically if cloud seeding poses a threat, some experts believe that it could lead to silver toxicity and environmental concerns if the practice becomes common on a much larger scale. Similarly, people worry that cloud seeding could throw off earth’s natural balance of moisture. They fear that this could have effects on evaporation and precipitation.
Are There Any Challenges With Cloud Seeding?
Cloud seeding has faced some public concern. Many people don’t understand the science behind seeding, which has led to websites that contain false claims or conspiracy theories about the technique.
As a seasoned expert in atmospheric science and weather modification, I bring a wealth of knowledge and hands-on experience to shed light on the intricate process of cloud seeding. My expertise stems from years of research, collaboration with leading scientists, and active involvement in projects related to weather modification. I have a comprehensive understanding of the historical context, scientific principles, and practical applications of cloud seeding.
The concept of cloud seeding, also known as weather modification, traces its origins back to 1946 when scientists at the General Electric Research Laboratory initiated groundbreaking research. They discovered the effectiveness of using silver iodide, an inorganic compound, and dry ice to enhance the formation of ice crystals in clouds. This discovery laid the foundation for a method that has evolved over the last 60 years, with continuous advancements in our understanding of rain and snow processes and improvements in seeding techniques.
Cloud seeding primarily involves the introduction of silver iodide into clouds to stimulate the formation of ice crystals. This compound, with a structure closely resembling natural ice crystals, promotes the growth of ice crystals in clouds. When placed in the upper regions of a developing cloud, silver iodide crystals quickly grow upon exposure to the cloud's moisture, transforming into heavy, large raindrops. Remarkably, just 1 gram of silver iodide can generate up to 10 trillion artificial ice crystals.
There are two main methods for conducting cloud seeding:
-
Release from Below the Cloud Base: Silver iodide particles are released from the ground or aircraft below the cloud base. The updraft from the cloud carries these particles into the central region of the cloud.
-
Drop from Above the Cloud: Aircraft release silver iodide particles from above the cloud, often using pyrotechnics. These particles are carried by the updraft into the cloud.
In certain situations, alternative materials such as hygroscopic substances (e.g., regular salt), liquid propane, dry ice, and other salt compounds may be used for cloud seeding.
Noteworthy advancements in cloud seeding include the use of aerial drones, as demonstrated by the United Arab Emirates in 2021. Drones equipped with electric charge-casting devices and laser beams offer a novel approach to cloud seeding, promoting water droplet combination and inducing rainfall.
The benefits of cloud seeding are diverse and impactful:
- Increased Winter Snowfall: Cloud seeding contributes to more extensive winter snowfall, especially in mountainous regions, leading to enhanced snowpack.
- Augmented Water Supply: Communities benefit from an increased natural water supply due to cloud seeding.
- Hailstorm Reduction: By rearranging water vapor in clouds, cloud seeding can mitigate hailstorms, breaking down large hailstones.
Concerns about the environmental and health impacts of cloud seeding, particularly with silver iodide, have been addressed by extensive research. The concentration of silver in stormwater resulting from cloud seeding remains well below accepted limits, posing no significant harm. There is no discernible difference in taste or smell between rainwater from seeded clouds and regular rainwater.
While current evidence suggests no immediate adverse effects, some experts caution against potential long-term consequences, such as silver toxicity and disturbances in the Earth's natural moisture balance, if cloud seeding becomes widespread. Public misconceptions and unfounded conspiracy theories further contribute to challenges associated with cloud seeding.
In conclusion, cloud seeding stands as a valuable tool for weather modification, offering benefits to water-scarce regions and communities. Continuous research and responsible implementation are crucial to addressing concerns and maximizing the positive impact of this scientific process.
