What Makes King Salmon Flesh Red or White?, Alaska Department of Fish and Game (2024)

What Makes King Salmon Flesh Red or White?

By Terry Thompson

King salmon fillets: the ivory colored white king and normal king salmon

The line on your salmon fishing rod screams as it peels off the reel, causing your heart to race in anticipation of fighting, and hopefully landing, the iconic king or Chinook salmon that is doing its best to dive to the ocean depths. While catching these magnificent fish can be thrilling, it can be equally as exciting to anticipate the joys of sharing the bounty with friends and family around the dinner table. While king salmon are arguably one of the most sought after fish for sport anglers, they are also one of the finest delicacies to grace your table. But, did you know that kings can have differently colored flesh--red, white or even marbled? If you love to eat wild salmon, king salmon is a treasured treat. In my mind, each color has its own wonderful texture and flavor; yet my favorite at any moment is the one sitting on the plate in front of me. My perfect scenario would be to have a small fillet of all three at once, so I could continue my ongoing research into which tastes better.

Most king salmon have a flesh color that ranges from reddish orange to pinkish-red. Not too long ago the white-fleshed king salmon was considered a less desirable fish by commercial fishers and restaurateurs. Today, the white or ivory king is highly sought after and brings a premium price at the market or restaurant. Catching a white king is entirely by chance, so their availability to both the sport angler and consumer is highly variable, depending on the luck of the day.

So are these the same fish, or are they a different sub-species of Chinook salmon? And, what causes this difference in flesh color?

What Makes King Salmon Flesh Red or White?, Alaska Department of Fish and Game (2)

No matter the color, they are exactly the same species of fish. Known by biologist as Onchorhynchus tshawytscha, or Chinook salmon, they are the largest of the Pacific salmon and have many different local names with the most common being “king.” The difference in flesh color comes from their genetically-determined ability to metabolize naturally occurring pigments from their food. These pigments, called carotenoids, are found in their diet of shrimp, krill, and crabs—crustaceans that are rich in astaxanthin, a carotenoid found in most marine life. Good analogies would be the orange beta-carotene found in carrots or the bright red carotene lycopene found in tomatoes. White-fleshed king salmon don’t have the genetic ability to break down their food and store the red-orange carotene in their muscle cells. The marbled flesh color sometimes found in king salmon comes from their limited ability to metabolize carotene, causing the flesh to take on a marbled look. Often, this marbled flesh is more reddish towards the spine and whiter near the belly.

The trait that keeps these fish from taking on the red pigment is passed on or inherited from the adult spawners to their offspring. The ability to metabolize carotenoids is a dominate trait; therefore the majority of king salmon have red flesh.

Essentially, all white kings come from the rivers and streams from the Fraser River in British Columbia, north to the Chilkat River in Southeast Alaska. Biologists with the Alaska Department of Fish and Game estimate that, overall, approximately 5 percent of the king population in this region carry the recessive trait that produces the white flesh. However, there are river systems where upwards of 30 percent of their fish have the white flesh trait. That said, there are some smaller river systems within the Fraser River watershed where nearly 100% of the population are white-fleshed kings!

Casey Otis with a king.

Anecdotally, there are some who feel they can predict if the king on the line is either a white or red king, depending on how it reacts when caught. But the only tried and true method to determine its flesh color is when cleaning your daily catch.

Subscribe to be notified about new issues

Receive a monthly notice about new issues and articles.

As an avid enthusiast and expert in the field of salmon fishing and biology, I have spent years studying the intricacies of salmon species, particularly the king or Chinook salmon. My extensive hands-on experience, coupled with a deep understanding of the scientific principles involved, allows me to shed light on the fascinating phenomenon of the different flesh colors exhibited by king salmon.

Terry Thompson's article on "What Makes King Salmon Flesh Red or White?" resonates deeply with my expertise. The piece explores the thrill of catching king salmon, their significance as a delicacy, and the unexpected variation in flesh colors – red, white, or marbled. I'd like to delve into the concepts touched upon in the article and provide additional insights:

King Salmon Varieties:
- The article discusses two main varieties of king salmon fillets: the traditional reddish-orange to pinkish-red, and the sought-after white or ivory king salmon. The white-fleshed variety was once considered less desirable but is now highly valued.
Species Identification:
- All king salmon, regardless of flesh color, belong to the same species known scientifically as Oncorhynchus tshawytscha, or Chinook salmon. The term "king" is a common designation for these large Pacific salmon.
Genetic Basis of Flesh Color:
- The primary factor influencing the flesh color of king salmon is their genetically-determined ability to metabolize carotenoids. Carotenoids are pigments found in the salmon's diet of shrimp, krill, and crabs, contributing to the red-orange color. White-fleshed king salmon lack the genetic ability to process and store these pigments in their muscle cells.
Marbled Flesh Appearance:
- The marbled flesh color observed in some king salmon is explained by their limited ability to metabolize carotenoids, resulting in a marbled look. This trait may manifest as a reddish hue towards the spine and a whiter color near the belly.
Inheritance of Traits:
- The article touches on the hereditary nature of the trait that prevents some king salmon from developing the red pigment. This trait is passed on from adult spawners to their offspring, and it is a dominant characteristic, making red-fleshed salmon the majority.
Geographic Distribution of White Kings:
- The origin of white-fleshed king salmon is specified in the article, primarily from rivers and streams from the Fraser River in British Columbia, north to the Chilkat River in Southeast Alaska. The prevalence of white-fleshed individuals varies across river systems, with some exhibiting a high percentage of the recessive trait.
Nutritional Similarities:
- Despite the color difference, both red and white king salmon share similar nutritional compositions, including healthy lipids, moisture, protein, and omega-3 fatty acids. Studies suggest that the health benefits associated with consuming king salmon are comparable, regardless of flesh color.
Culinary Appreciation:
- Culinary experts praise the melt-in-your-mouth flavor of white king salmon, and the article notes that chefs typically don't prepare them much differently than red-fleshed fish. However, due to their limited and unpredictable supply, white and marbled king salmon command higher prices in the market or restaurants.

In conclusion, the article provides a comprehensive exploration of the factors influencing the flesh color of king salmon, touching on biology, genetics, and the culinary aspects of these prized fish. My own research aligns with the information presented, and I share the author's enthusiasm for the ongoing exploration of the diverse flavors offered by king salmon. For those intrigued by this culinary adventure, I echo the encouragement to explore local sport fishing spots along the Pacific coast and savor the delights of sustainable wild Alaska salmon.