The Reason Burger King Was Originally More Expensive Than Competitors - Tasting Table (2024)

Culture

SrideeStudio/Shutterstock

ByEmily Boyette/Sept. 30, 2022 1:00 pm EST

See Also

Burger King to sell 37-cent Whoppers in honor of its birthdayWhite CastleWhy Doesn't White Castle Franchise?Interactive: How Much Did Your Favorite Burger Cost 30 Years Ago?

Home of the Whopper, Chicken Fries, and the beloved Cini-Minis, it's no secret that Burger King has menu staples that stand out. Originating in Jacksonville, Florida in 1954, Burger King is the second largest fast food burger chain in the world (per Common Cents Mom). BK's focus on quality ingredients is just the tip of the iceberg for why they've been successful, yet their prices seem to have been significantly higher than other fast food chains in the past (via Food Business News).

According to Insider, the average price of a hamburger in 1978 was 64 cents, yet a Whopper from Burger King was $1.09. In 1982, the average price of a burger was 70 cents, while Burger King sold its burgers for $1.39. From 1985 to 1997, Burger King reduced its burger price to 99 cents, yet it still exceeded the price of McDonald's during that time. By the time McDonald's burger price reached $1 in 2012, Burger King's burgers had reached $3.15.Boston 25 News states that when the Whopper was first introduced to the Burger King menu in 1957, it cost 37 cents. So, what gives; is the King just greedy?

The Whopper is hefty

Michael Thomas/Getty Images

Not really. That's because until McDonald's released their own 4 ounce patty with the Quarter Pounder in 1971, the Whopper had no real rival in the market. Yes, the Whopper cost more than an average hamburger, but it was no average hamburger.The Whopper patty at 4 ounces weighed slightly more than an entire McDonald's hamburger at 3.7 ouncesaccording to Insider.James McLamore, founder and first CEO of Burger King, witnessed customers flocking to a Florida burger joint and owed it to the size of the burger and opted to do the same(via The New York Times).

See Also

13News Now Vault: Comparing today's fast food prices to ones from 1981

If we really want to compare apples to apples, we should compare the cost of BK's Whopper and McDonald's Quarter Pounder, and the current difference in price isn't that considerable. Today, according to Fast Food Menu Prices, a Whopper costs$4.19, while a Quarter Pounder (with cheese) costs$3.79. It does seem that today the Whopper is a bit pricier than its rival, but they also flame broil their hamburgers, and they think that's worth something.

Recommended

As an avid enthusiast and expert in the fast-food industry, particularly in the history and pricing strategies of major chains like Burger King, I can confidently provide insights into the concepts mentioned in the article. My knowledge extends beyond the surface, delving into the intricate details that have shaped the competitive landscape of fast-food giants.

The article touches upon several key elements, and I'll break down the concepts discussed:

1. Burger King's History and Origins:

   • Burger King originated in Jacksonville, Florida, in 1954, making it one of the longstanding players in the fast-food industry.

2. Menu Staples and Signature Items:

   • The article highlights some of Burger King's iconic menu items, including the Whopper, Chicken Fries, and Cini-Minis, showcasing the diversity and popularity of their offerings.

3. Market Positioning and Size:

   • Burger King is recognized as the second-largest fast-food burger chain globally, emphasizing its significant market presence and influence.

4. Quality Ingredients and Success Factors:

   • The success of Burger King is attributed, in part, to its focus on quality ingredients. This emphasis on providing higher-quality food may have contributed to its sustained success over the years.

5. Pricing Strategies Over Time:

   • The article discusses the evolution of Burger King's pricing strategies, noting that historically, their prices were higher than the average fast-food burger. It provides specific examples of price differentials over various years, showcasing the changes in pricing dynamics.

6. Comparison with Competitors, Specifically McDonald's:

   • The article draws comparisons between Burger King and McDonald's, highlighting instances where Burger King's prices exceeded those of McDonald's. It notes the historical context of these comparisons and how Burger King adjusted its pricing strategy over time.

7. Product Differentiation - Whopper vs. Quarter Pounder:

   • A significant point of comparison is the Whopper's size and weight in relation to its price. The article mentions that, historically, the Whopper had no direct rival until McDonald's introduced the Quarter Pounder in 1971. The Whopper's larger size justified its higher cost.

8. Founder's Influence - James McLamore:

   • James McLamore, the founder and first CEO of Burger King, played a pivotal role in observing market trends and responding to customer preferences. His decision to offer a larger burger was influenced by customer demand, a strategy that contributed to the Whopper's success.

9. Current Price Comparison:

   • The article concludes by providing a current price comparison between the Whopper and McDonald's Quarter Pounder, suggesting that the price difference is not as considerable when comparing similar products.

In summary, my comprehensive understanding of the fast-food industry allows me to dissect and analyze the nuanced factors contributing to Burger King's pricing strategies and its historical positioning in the market.