Freeze Dried Vs. Canned: The Pros and Cons in Food Storage (2024)

Gear

Survival Gear

Freeze Dried Vs. Canned: The Pros and Cons in Food Storage (1)

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn More ›

Buying a large volume of food is a serious investment in your survival. It can also be a bad investment if no emergency comes and you are stuck eating hundreds of meals that you find nauseating. There are plenty of food storage options out there for purchase, ranging from historic preservation methods to the latest technology. Let’s look at the pros and cons of the two most popular food storage systems–freeze-dried and canned–to determine which is the better preservation method for you.

The Pros of Freeze Dried
The process of freeze drying food and medicine is time-tested. Medicines were freeze dried in World War II for stable transport, and freeze dried meals have been around for decades. The two primary benefits of going the freeze dried route with your survival meals are that 1.) The meals are lightweight and 2.) They have a long shelf life. With the weight of water removed, most meals are a fraction of the weight of the original food. This is ideal for backpacking and bugging out. The careful packaging of freeze dried goods will keep the food safe and edible for many years. A side benefit from this drying process is the improved preservation of vitamins and other nutrients over the damaging heat of the canning process.

The Cons of Freeze Dried
The two biggest cons of freeze dried food are the price and the fact that preparation is required for most foods. Freeze dried food can cost as much as $8 a meal. This can add up fast if you are purchasing for a large group or for a long span of time. And while some dried meals and foods are ready-to-eat or just need cold water, most meals need hot water. This means you have to get a cooking source fired up, heat some water, and wait for the food to cook or properly rehydrate. The packaging is also more vulnerable to rodents and insects than cans. Unless you are ordering from a manufacturer, you may have a hard time finding the meals and foods you are looking for, as most stores do not sell that many freeze dried foods.

The Pros of Canned
Availability, cost, and durability are the three main perks of going with canned foods. Any grocery store in the land will supply us with cans of chili, soup, meat, fish, and even canned bread and crackers. The cost is about one third the price of freeze dried food (per meal, on average). The cans are also rodent and insect proof.

The Cons of Canned
Canned food is heavy, it doesn’t last as long as freeze dried food, and many vitamins are destroyed by the heat used in canning the food. You also need a can opener unless you are dealing with a pop-top can, which is less durable than a regular can. Another problem is that cans will burst if frozen severely enough. This makes canned food a bad choice for winter survival food in a vehicle.

So Which Do You Buy?
For most disaster preparedness scenarios, I recommend a mixture of freeze dried and canned food. You cover more bases by diversifying. For example, if rats get into your freeze dried pouches, at least the cans are still good. If the temperature unexpectedly dips below freezing, the freeze dried pouches will be unharmed while the cans may be bursting. Going with just one strategy can make sense if you know what will happen at your storage site. Go with freeze dried if you know it will freeze. Go with canned if it will always be above freezing, but the food containers could be breached by animals. If you have a remote cabin or rarely visited site in a cold area, you can also “double-up” your security by placing freeze dried pouches in a tightly sealed metal cans or metal boxes. This takes care of both the critters and the cold.

Do you prefer one method over the other? Let us know in the comments.

Freeze Dried Vs. Canned: The Pros and Cons in Food Storage (2024)

FAQs

Freeze Dried Vs. Canned: The Pros and Cons in Food Storage? ›

A side benefit from this drying process is the improved preservation of vitamins and other nutrients over the damaging heat of the canning process. The two biggest cons of freeze dried food are the price and the fact that preparation is required for most foods. Freeze dried food can cost as much as $8 a meal.

Is freeze-dried better than canned? ›

In the quest to preserve our favorite foods, freeze drying and canning emerge as contenders. However, when it comes to retaining nutritional value, freeze drying takes a clear lead.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of freeze dryer? ›

Overall, freeze-drying has unique advantages when it comes to maintaining product quality, extending shelf life, and ease of storage, but may be subject to some limitations in terms of cost and speed.

Is freeze-dried food positive or negative? ›

It is a healthy food preservation method, as it retains most of the beneficial plant compounds and nutrients in foods, as well as their color, taste, and appearance. However, it doesn't kill harmful bacteria. Therefore, you should thoroughly cook freeze-dried raw foods like meat or eggs.

Why doesn't freeze-dried food go bad? ›

Because 98-99 percent of the moisture in food being freeze-dried is removed during the process, it has a shelf life of usually 25 years or more. In both cases, cooler temperatures will help lengthen shelf life.

What are the disadvantages of freeze-dried food? ›

Disadvantages:
  • Water required for reconstitution (except for simple snacks)
  • Slow process — average cycle is 24+ hours.
  • Some dislike the dry, styrofoam texture.
  • Not all foods can be freeze dried.
  • Airtight containers are required for long-term storage.
  • No space savings — the food's cellular structure is mostly retained.

What is the most nutritious freeze-dried food? ›

The healthiest freeze dried foods are whole, real foods that have been frozen to retain their natural nutritional value. These foods include eggs, seafood, vegetables and dark colored berries such as acai, blueberry, strawberry and raspberries.

What foods cannot be freeze-dried? ›

Here are some of the few foods that aren't suitable for freeze drying:
  • Fatty meats.
  • Meat containing bones.
  • Butter.
  • Pure chocolate.
  • Coffee beans.
  • Honey.
  • Jams and jellies.
  • Mayonnaise.
Nov 29, 2023

How long does a freeze dryer last? ›

While it is true that some freeze dryers continue to lyophilize effectively for decades, the average life span of a freeze dryer in today's laboratory environment is approximately 10 to 15 years. Do you want to know the secrets to getting that much life out of your freeze dryer?

What's the point of freeze drying? ›

The primary purpose of freeze drying within the food industry is to extend the shelf-life of the food while maintaining the quality. Freeze-drying is known to result in the highest quality of foods of all drying techniques because structural integrity is maintained along with preservation of flavors.

Can bacteria grow on freeze-dried food? ›

Microbiologists and veterinary nutritionists tell us that freeze-drying is one of the best ways to preserve bacteria. Because the technique helps bacteria remain viable and healthy for decades, freeze-dried raw food is just as risky as unprocessed raw food.

How is freeze-drying bad for you? ›

Freeze drying uses the process of sublimation and removes the water from the food while it's still in its ice form. However, since it removes the water, it can also remove some water-soluble nutrients such as vitamin C and folate.

Can freeze-dried fruit have mold? ›

Freeze Dried Fruit vs.

By removing the moisture from fruits, including bananas, most berries, apples, dragon fruits, apricots, and pineapples, the food becomes more shelf-stable and resistant to mold or rot, which plagues fresh fruits as they age.

Can botulism grow in freeze-dried food? ›

Fortunately, without moisture (water) the botulism bacteria (and all bacteria, yeast, and molds) cannot grow. Therefore, it is safe to place properly dried or freeze-dried foods in vacuum packaging or in containers that also have oxygen absorber packets placed inside.

How long will freeze-dried food last without oxygen absorbers? ›

Once opened, most freeze-dried foods should last 6-12 months. Exposure to heat, light, oxygen, and moisture indicates how long the opened can of freeze-dried food will last. You can prolong shelf life by storing your food in a dark, cool place and in the most airtight containers possible.

What is the best way to store food for years? ›

If sealed properly and stored in ideal conditions, food kept in plastic buckets can last up to five years or even 20 years if oxygen absorbers are used. Regardless of your packaging, dry foods such as rice and beans store best in oxygen-free, cool and dark environments.

Is freeze-dried stuff healthier? ›

Freeze-dried foods retain the vast majority of the vitamins and minerals found in their original state. Freeze-dried food retains its nutrition because of the “cold, vacuum” process that is used to extract the water. Whereas, the nutritional value of dehydrated food is generally around 60% of equivalent fresh food.

Is freeze-dried cat food better than wet food? ›

Between freeze-dried cat food lasting longer than canned cat food and having consistently high quality and taste, significantly lower pricing, and unmatched nutrition and serving options, there's no need to be nervous about trying freeze-dried options.

Why is freeze-dried better? ›

Freeze-drying retains nutritional value better than other drying methods, further supporting consumers' desire for nutrition from whole foods. The process also preserves the actual color and shape of the original raw material, reassuring consumers they are actually getting real fruits and vegetables in their diets.

Is freezing better than canning? ›

While the University of Alaska did find that canning was the most cost-effective method of preserving food, they also found that freezing was the best way to retain nutrients. Coastal Tip: Try freezing or canning vegetables together, such as a stir-fry mix.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 6256

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.