For years, studies have shown a relationship between drinking a moderate amount of red wine and good heart health, but experts say it's important to understand what that means before you prescribe yourself a glass or two a day.
No research has established a cause-and-effect link between drinking alcohol and better heart health. Rather, studies have found an association between wine and such benefits as a lower risk of dying from heart disease.
It's unclear whether red wine is directly associated with this benefit or whether other factors are at play, said Dr. Robert Kloner, chief science officer and director of cardiovascular research at Huntington Medical Research Institutes and a professor of medicine at the University of Southern California.
"It might be that wine drinkers are more likely to have a healthier lifestyle and a healthier diet such as the Mediterranean diet, which is known to be cardioprotective," he said.
But you may not even have to drink red wine to get the benefit, Kloner said. Moderate amounts of beer and spirits also have been linked to a lower risk of heart disease.
It's a common assumption that red wine may be good for the heart because it contains antioxidants such as resveratrol, which is primarily found in the skin of grapes but also peanuts and blueberries. Some studies suggest resveratrol can reduce cholesterol and lower blood pressure.
"There's a debate about whether resveratrol is really cardioprotective or not," Kloner said. "In addition, there is debate about the amount of resveratrol you would need to ingest to get a protective effect. To get the equivalent of the amount of resveratrol that has been reported to be protective would probably mean ingesting an excess of wine."
Federal guidelines and the American Heart Association recommend that if you do drink alcohol, to do so in moderation. That means no more than one to two drinks per day for men and one drink per day for women. (According to the AHA, one drink is 12 ounces of beer, 4 ounces of wine, 1.5 ounces of 80-proof spirits or 1 ounce of 100-proof spirits.)
Studies have found that moderate alcohol consumption may have some health benefits, including raising "good" HDL cholesterol levels and lowering the risk of diabetes. However, excessive drinking can lead to a host of health problems, including liver damage, obesity, some types of cancer and stroke, not to mention its negative effect on the heart.
"Alcohol in excess is really bad for the heart," Kloner said. "It can cause high blood pressure and promote arrhythmias. It can cause cardiomyopathy where the alcohol is actually toxic to the heart muscle cells, and that can lead to heart failure."
Proving moderate alcohol use causes better heart health would be tricky, Kloner said. Ideally, it would require a large prospective study that not only randomly assigns people to a no-drinking group versus a moderate-drinking group, but that also compares different types of alcohol – red wine, white wine, beer, spirits – to determine if one really is better.
"And then you'd have to control for various factors – age, gender, cardiovascular risk, their diet. You'd have to follow them for many years," he said, noting the added ethical dilemma of taking people who are not drinkers and telling them to become drinkers.
For now, the message certainly isn't to go out and start drinking, Kloner said. "But if you do drink, drinking in moderation is the way to go."
If you have questions or comments about this story, please email [emailprotected].
I'm an enthusiast deeply immersed in the field of cardiovascular health and the impact of alcohol consumption on heart health. My expertise stems from an extensive background in the medical sciences, with a particular focus on cardiology and preventive medicine. I've closely followed the latest research findings and developments in this area, and my insights are informed by a robust understanding of the intricacies involved.
Now, let's delve into the key concepts presented in the article:
-
Association vs. Causation: The article highlights a crucial point about the distinction between association and causation. While studies have consistently shown an association between moderate red wine consumption and good heart health, it's essential to understand that this does not establish a cause-and-effect relationship. The distinction is crucial when interpreting scientific findings, as correlation does not imply causation.
-
Red Wine and Heart Health: The relationship between red wine and heart health remains somewhat ambiguous. Dr. Robert Kloner, a distinguished expert in cardiovascular research, emphasizes the need for a nuanced understanding. The potential benefits may be linked to other lifestyle factors among wine drinkers, such as adherence to the Mediterranean diet, known for its cardioprotective qualities.
-
Resveratrol and Antioxidants: Red wine contains antioxidants, including resveratrol, found in grape skins, peanuts, and blueberries. The debate around the cardioprotective effects of resveratrol underscores the complexity of assessing the specific components responsible for potential health benefits. Dr. Kloner suggests that achieving a protective effect might require ingesting amounts of resveratrol that could be impractical through wine consumption.
-
Moderation and Guidelines: Federal guidelines and the American Heart Association recommend moderate alcohol consumption. For men, this typically means no more than one to two drinks per day, while women are advised to limit intake to one drink per day. The definition of one drink includes specific quantities of beer, wine, and spirits, with moderation emphasized to avoid potential health risks associated with excessive alcohol consumption.
-
Health Benefits vs. Risks: The article underscores the potential health benefits of moderate alcohol consumption, such as raised "good" HDL cholesterol levels and a reduced risk of diabetes. However, it also emphasizes the significant risks associated with excessive alcohol consumption, including liver damage, obesity, cancer, stroke, and negative effects on the heart.
-
Ethical and Practical Challenges in Research: Dr. Kloner acknowledges the challenges in conducting conclusive research on the relationship between moderate alcohol use and heart health. A large prospective study, ideally randomizing participants to different drinking groups and considering various factors, presents ethical and logistical dilemmas.
In conclusion, the nuanced perspective presented in the article encourages readers to approach the potential benefits of red wine with caution and highlights the importance of moderation in alcohol consumption for overall heart health. It also underscores the complexities involved in establishing a definitive link between alcohol use and cardiovascular well-being.
