Why Ice Cream Cake Is Better Than Regular Cake | undefined (2024)

ATK Kids

Three reasons you should celebrate with ice cream cake instead of regular cake.

Why Ice Cream Cake Is Better Than Regular Cake | undefined (1)By

Published June 9, 2022.

Why Ice Cream Cake Is Better Than Regular Cake | undefined (2)

I’m a firm believer that ice cream cake is always better than regular cake, no matter the occasion. I get the appeal of a traditional layer cake, but the cake often ends up dry and the frosting can be almost too rich.

Maybe it’s childhood nostalgia for the Carvel ice cream cake that was on the table at my birthday every year, but I’m not sure there’s anything better than two layers of ice cream sandwiching a layer of crunchy cookies.

Not convinced yet? Here are three reasons ice cream cake should be on the menu at your next celebration.

Sign up for the Cook's Country Dinner Tonight newsletter

10 ingredients. 45 minutes. Quick, easy, and fresh weeknight recipes.

America's Test Kitchen will not sell, rent, or disclose your email address to third parties unless otherwise notified. Your email address is required to identify you for free access to content on the site. You will also receive free newsletters and notification of America's Test Kitchen specials.

The flavor combinations are endless

Regular cake has its limits—there are only a handful of cake and frosting flavors to choose from. But you can use literally ANY ice cream flavor in an ice cream cake—there are no wrong answers here. And since our recipe makes a two-layer treat, you get to use two different flavors. Then, you can customize your cake even more with . . . the crunchies! While Carvel’s chocolate bits will always have a special place in my heart, crushing up your favorite cookies or candies is even better—and lets you get out some pent-up aggression too.

It’s so easy that a 5-year-old can make it

Making an ice cream cake couldn’t be easier: no oven, no knife, just a freezer and some time to kill. It is worth investing in a springform pan to help with shaping and serving. And I wasn’t joking about the 5-year-olds: This recipe appears in our cookbook designed for kids ages 5 and up, My First Cookbook. Six-year-old recipe tester Benjamin declared, “It was fun, especially the cookie-crushing act!”

Book

Buy Now

It’s the ideal make-ahead dessert

An assembled ice cream cake can hang out in the freezer, wrapped in plastic wrap, for up to a week, which is perfect if you’re planning ahead for a party, or if you just want to eat it on your own, slice by slice.

Why Ice Cream Cake Is Better Than Regular Cake | undefined (3)

Mint Chip Ice Cream Cake

This no-bake ice cream cake is filled with layers of chocolate and mint chip ice cream, but you can use ANY flavors you’d like!

Get the Recipe

Why Ice Cream Cake Is Better Than Regular Cake | undefined (2024)

FAQs

Why Ice Cream Cake Is Better Than Regular Cake | undefined? ›

The flavor combinations are endless

What is the difference between ice cake and regular cake? ›

The simple cake is a cake without any buttercream icing whereas the ice cake is covered with cream frosting.

What is interesting about ice cream cake? ›

Ice cream cake was originally made from biscuits and cream. Victorian era desserts called bombes consisted of ice cream and fruit in decorative molds. Sometimes these desserts were lined with cake or biscuits. Ice cream cake recipes dating to the 1870s have also been found.

What is the difference between a cream cake and a normal cake? ›

Cream cakes look fluffy and soft whereas fondant cakes look silky and slightly rigid. In regards to the weight, fondant cakes are heavy than cream cakes. Cream icing is made using butter, sugar, and cream, whereas fondant icing is made using gelatine, glucose, and sugar.

How many people prefer ice cream over cake? ›

According to a recent survey by Yahoo Inc, which interviewed over 1000 people around the USA, 41% of Americans choose ice cream as their favorite dessert, followed by 20% choosing cake, 11% cookies and 9% fruit.

Is ice cream healthier than cake? ›

Ice cream's low glycemic index, minerals, and vitamins make it a healthier choice compared to other desserts such as candy, soda, or cake. Although ice cream is a dessert, it can be eaten in moderation. Remember, the research is based on eating only one-half cup of ice cream per day.

Are frozen cakes as good as fresh? ›

Good news – most homemade cakes and bakes freeze well, and by following a few key guidelines, most sweet treats will taste just as good after freezing as the day you baked them. After baking your cake, ensure that it fully cools before freezing.

Why is ice cream the best dessert? ›

Ice cream is the best dessert for a number of reasons. It's refreshing, comes in a wide variety of flavors, is versatile, easy to find, and affordable. It's also a crowd-pleaser that can be enjoyed year-round and is a good source of calcium. And of course, it's delicious!

How does ice cream cake make you feel? ›

About the Ice Cream Cake Strain

This strain has a distinct sweet aroma and a fruity taste reminiscent of cookies and cherry pie. Tokers say its benefits include increased appetite, calming and soothing effects, and anxiety and depression relief. It is potent, with THC levels ranging from 25 to 27%.

When did ice cream cake become popular? ›

Ice cream cakes really took off in popularity in the 1970s when cakes like Fudgie the Whale, Carvel's iconic iced brown chocolate ice cream cake with a clever smile, and “Happy Birthday” scrawled across it with white icing, became popular.

Which type of cake is more tasty? ›

Chocolate is often touted to be one of the best cake flavours. It's almost impossible to resist a slice of gooey, moist chocolate cake. These cakes are made with chocolate sponge, layered with chocolate ganache or mousse, or topped with truffle frosting.

What is a cake without cream called? ›

Oil Cake. Oil cakes follow the same principles as butter cakes, but use oil as the source of fat. Because oil is liquid at room temperature, oil cake recipes skip the step of creaming the fat and sugar; usually the oil is incorporated into the wet ingredients, which are whisked or folded into the dry ingredients.

Which cake is more taste? ›

Chocolate Cake. If there's one dessert that can tempt even the most disciplined among us, it's chocolate cake. The soft, moist layers of cake practically melt in your mouth, while the creamy, velvety frosting brings a burst of flavour with every bite.

What is the #1 ice cream in America? ›

Ice cream brands in the U.S.

Private-label once again leads Ben & Jerry's. However, the distance between branded offers and private-label products is much larger. Private-label products sold 401 million units, over double Ben & Jerry's 176 million units sold. Ben & Jerry's is number one in.

Is ice cream more popular than cake? ›

Ice cream is America's favorite dessert. When asked to choose a favorite dessert, ice cream is the obvious winner and is twice as popular as its closest competitor, cake.

What gender buys the most ice cream? ›

Key Market Issues

The population of the UK is fairly evenly split between Males and Females; however, Females consume more Impulse Ice Cream than Males. Marketers should consider gender, differentiating their campaigns in order to attract more Male consumers and increase consumption among Females.

Do frozen cakes taste the same? ›

It can save you hours in the kitchen, and keeping your cakes cold won't harm the taste if done right. In my years as a cake artist, I have found that when you use the freezer properly, it can even add to the cake's flavor and stability.

What is ice cake made of? ›

To construct your ice cream cake, you'll be alternating layers of ice cream with cake, or with crumbled cookies, or even with dessert sauces like chocolate or butterscotch. When making an ice cream cake, it's essential to work quickly, so that the ice cream doesn't melt.

What is the difference between frosted cake and iced cake? ›

You'll be glad to know there is a distinction between the two. In broad terms, frosting is thick and fluffy, and is used to coat the outside (and often the inner layers) of a cake. Icing is thinner and glossier than frosting, and can be used as a glaze or for detailed decorating.

Does ice cream cake have real cake in it? ›

Ice Cream Cake Doesn't Involve Cake At All

It is composed of layers of ice cream with some fun goodies in between, made in a cake pan and frosted like a normal cake would be. It cut just like a regular cake and has a cool and refreshing flavor that is perfect for summertime.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 6027

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Birthday: 1996-12-09

Address: Apt. 141 1406 Mitch Summit, New Teganshire, UT 82655-0699

Phone: +2296092334654

Job: Technology Architect

Hobby: Snowboarding, Scouting, Foreign language learning, Dowsing, Baton twirling, Sculpting, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Francesca Jacobs Ret, I am a innocent, super, beautiful, charming, lucky, gentle, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.