Tree-planting: Why are large investment firms buying Welsh farms? (2024)

  • Published

Tree-planting: Why are large investment firms buying Welsh farms? (1)

By Rachael Garside & Iola Wyn

BBC News

Plans to encourage more trees to be planted in Wales are under fire for "destroying communities" in rural areas.

Large-scale investment companies have been buying farms across the country for afforestation - planting trees to offset carbon emissions.

But there are concerns it could damage local culture, language and heritage.

The Welsh government said it would launch a consultation on its National Forest plan.

About 12 farms have been sold recently in mid Wales by companies outside the country, according to an agricultural expert.

Wales has declared a climate emergency and pledged to be at least 95% carbon neutral by 2050.

The Welsh government last year launched a plan to create a National Forest for Wales, promising to increase the number of trees being planted every year to improve air quality and reduce greenhouse gases.

The policy aimed to "create woodlands that are accessible to people and give local communities the opportunity to get involved, helping to promote Welsh language, culture and heritage".

But there are calls to make urgent changes to the strategy, which currently allows companies outside Wales to take advantage of forestry grants.

'It's breaking my heart'

After living and working on Frongoch Farm in Carmarthenshire's Cothi Valley for nearly 70 years, it was a wrench for John Thomas to sell the farm when he retired three years ago.

He hoped the new owners would take care of his family home in Cwrt y Cadno and safeguard it for future generations of farmers.

But it was resold earlier this year to a multi-national investment company called Foresight Group, based at the Shard in London.

At auction, the guide price was exceeded and the farm, together with another local holding, sold for more than £2m.

Mr Thomas said it was "breaking my heart" to see his childhood home become one of many sold to "huge, faceless companies in England" for planting trees.

"I feel very sad about it - I feel quite angry actually," he said.

"It shouldn't be allowed to happen on such a big scale. It's shameful that they should be allowed to do this.

The Foresight Group owns four farms in Wales - Frongoch, Brynglas, Esgair Hir and Banc - and confirmed that it intended to use the land for afforestation.

The company said: "Sustainability is central to Foresight's business and we believe it is right to invest responsibly in forestry sites around the UK.

"A key focus of our approach is to ensure that any land use change is done in as sensitive way as possible. As part of any new scheme, we always engage and consult with local communities."

The company added it targeted less fertile land for afforestation projects and confirmed it intended to apply for Welsh government grants.

'It's our heritage'

Susan Price, who lives on a farm near Llanwrtyd Wells in Powys, said there were three farms in the area which had been recently sold to companies from outside Wales to plant trees.

She said taking fertile land out of food production into forestry was harmful for the local agricultural industry and damaged the local culture and language.

"I feel quite bitter because it's part of our heritage," added Ms Price.

"When our livelihoods are taken away from us, then our heritage and our communities and our language disappear and I think it's very sad.

She said large companies bought land as investment, "outpricing local families", and the Welsh government was "making it so easy for them" through its grant system.

"I don't suppose you can blame them - it's here for them on a plate and they're going to take it up, but unfortunately, we have to lose things because of it," she said.

Dai Dyer, an agricultural consultant in the Tywi Valley, Carmarthenshire, has researched the buying and selling of farms in mid and south-west Wales.

He warned the buying up of farms for tree planting became "a trend that might not be able to be stopped", turning "fruitful, productive farms that also house families" into "a house surrounded by trees".

He added the grant scheme should only be offered to those living in Wales and the amount of planting on anyone holding restricted to 10%.

The Welsh government said: "The Woodland Investment Grant Scheme is not a land purchase scheme.

"It is unlikely investors buying land for planting trees on a large scale will apply to the scheme, unless they are aiming to create a woodland area for local communities."

The Welsh government added a formal consultation on the National Forest scheme would be launched shortly to engage with local communities and farmers.

Related Topics

  • Sheep farming
  • Wales
  • Greenhouse gas emissions
  • Mid and West Wales
  • Trees
  • Greenhouse gas monitoring
  • Welsh language
  • Agriculture
  • London
  • Welsh government
  • Environment
  • Sustainable agriculture
  • Forest
  • Carbon footprint
  • Intensive farming
  • Llanwrtyd Wells

More on this story

  • Largest trees planted to offset lifetime emissions

  • Plans for Welsh national forest to be launched

    • Published

      12 March 2020

  • Farming fear over plans to plant 20 million trees

    • Published

      21 January 2020

  • Giant sign cut into bracken on Black Mountains

    • Published

      23 September 2020

  • 'Disappointing' tree planting as Wales lags behind

    • Published

      16 June 2020

  • Wales' woodlands 'facing catastrophe'

    • Published

      14 April 2021

  • Deaths on Welsh farms more than double in a year

    • Published

      20 July 2021

  • Farming pollution rules defended by first minister

    • Published

      2 February 2021

  • Bid to scrap Wales' farming pollution rules fails

    • Published

      3 March 2021

  • Would you be-leaf it? Tea is being grown in Wales

    • Published

      9 July 2021

Tree-planting: Why are large investment firms buying Welsh farms? (2024)

FAQs

What is the Welsh government target for tree planting? ›

1.1 The Welsh Government (WG) has committed to support the planting of 180,000 hectares of trees by 2050 as part of their Net Zero strategy1. The future carbon profile of Wales and reaching Wales's Net Zero targets2 depend on the delivery of increased woodland3.

Why are Welsh farmers protesting? ›

Across Europe, farmers are protesting against changes to regulations and subsidy schemes. Smaller protests have spread through the UK – particularly in Wales, where thousands have turned out to air their grievances with the recent update to the Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS).

What is the woodland planting scheme Wales? ›

The scheme provides funding for the planting of trees and the installation of fencing and gates. It also offers 12 years of maintenance and premium payments (compensation for loss of agricultural income). Planting trees under the scheme will not affect Basic Payment Scheme (BPS) payments or land eligibility.

What are the benefits of tree farms? ›

While the seedlings are growing they continue to support life by absorbing carbon dioxide and other gases and emit fresh oxygen. Farms that grow Christmas trees stabilize soil, protect water supplies and provide refuge for wildlife while creating scenic green belts.

What has the Welsh Government set as a target for Welsh speakers by 2050? ›

The Welsh Government has set two ambitious targets by 2050, namely to reach a million Welsh speakers, and to double the percentage of the population who use Welsh daily. The Government's Cymraeg 2050 strategy emphasises the central importance of the education sector in achieving this goal.

How do I get a free tree to plant in Wales? ›

The scheme, run by the Welsh Government and Coed Cadw, the Woodland Trust in Wales will help tackle the effects of climate change and will also contribute to the National Forest for Wales. Between now and March 2023 there are 295,000 trees available to households that fill in a Plant a Tree for Me online form.

What is the problem with Welsh farming? ›

We want to keep Welsh farmers farming, as we tackle the climate and nature emergency. The sector is facing significant challenges as a result of persistently high inflation and energy costs, global instability, high input costs and volatile farmgate prices together with substantial change in the industry.

What is happening with Welsh farmers? ›

What are the farmers protesting about? The main trigger for the protests are proposals in the Welsh government's sustainable farming scheme (SFS) – its post-Brexit plan for funding the industry from 2025. One of the ideas is that farmers should commit to ensuring 10% of their land is under tree cover.

What is happening to Welsh farming? ›

Sustainable Farming Scheme

This is the Welsh government's big plan for funding the industry after Brexit - which puts a lot more emphasis on the environment. In order to gain access to the scheme, farmers will have to commit to having trees on 10% of their land, and earmark another 10% as wildlife habitat.

Is UK woodland a good investment? ›

Woodland values are far less volatile than many more traditional financial market investments and complement any portfolio. The long term nature of a woodland investment provides a high degree of stability and growth patterns are historically very reliable.

Why would you buy woodland UK? ›

Financial benefits of owning woodland

Enterprises sometimes involve ancient and highly sustainable activities such as coppicing and charcoal burning. Commercial woodland is also often used for leisure pursuits such as paintballing, bushcraft and similar courses.

How to make money out of woodland UK? ›

Forestry as an investment

As with most assets, there are two main ways to make money from trees: capital gains and income. So you can buy a plot of woodland and hope that it goes up in value by the time you come to sell it. Or you can buy a forest and sell the timber that it produces.

What are the disadvantages of tree farms? ›

Many plantations, being made of single species and well trimmed, often do not hold a variety of wildlife. They are generally more susceptible to disease and insect attack, and often to fires as well. And many plantations are NOT sustainable years without extensive chemical support.

Why do farmers have trees in their fields? ›

The trees provide shade and shelter to the crops, and their deeper root systems help the soil retain moisture.

How do tree farms affect the environment? ›

“But while biodiverse forests support the livelihoods of Indigenous Peoples and other forest dependent people around the world, tree plantations generally produce low-quality timber for making disposable paper products, while taking away local people's land, destroying biodiversity, depleting water resources, and ...

What is the purpose and role of the Welsh Government woodland Estate? ›

The purpose and role of the Welsh Government Woodland Estate

The woodland estate helps to tackle climate change by locking up carbon. It also provides valuable habitats for plants and wildlife and offers space for recreation. It provides a good supply of timber, which supports employment and rural livelihoods.

What is the UK woodland Creation target? ›

Rates of woodland creation need to accelerate to capture carbon and to help biodiversity. To meet legally binding environmental targets, we need to increase tree cover from 14.5% to 16.5% by 2050.

What is the Wales Action Plan for Pollinators? ›

This final plan sets the strategic vision, outcomes and areas for action to improve conditions for pollinators and work to halt and reverse their decline in Wales. An implementation plan will be developed and delivered by a Pollinators delivery group, within the Wales Biodiversity Framework.

What is the UK tree planting policy? ›

This would require UK tree planting rates to rise to between 30–50,000 hectares per year 9 and stay at this level until 2050 to reach the predicted necessary contribution to net zero. The Government has committed to a UK-wide target of creating 30,000 hectares a year of new woodland by 2025.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jamar Nader

Last Updated:

Views: 6832

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jamar Nader

Birthday: 1995-02-28

Address: Apt. 536 6162 Reichel Greens, Port Zackaryside, CT 22682-9804

Phone: +9958384818317

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Scrapbooking, Hiking, Hunting, Kite flying, Blacksmithing, Video gaming, Foraging

Introduction: My name is Jamar Nader, I am a fine, shiny, colorful, bright, nice, perfect, curious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.