Mystery shopping controls on the compliance of alcohol sales points with the legal age limit have found that alcohol remains easily and widely available to underage youth in Switzerland, with one in five minors being able to purchase alcohol.
6534 tests were carried out across Switzerland on behalf of the Federal Customs Administration (FCA) in 2019. The mystery shopping found that on average one in five (20. 3%) minors were able to purchase alcohol despite the legal age limit. This is a 10% drop since 2016. In Switzerland, the minimum age to purchase alcohol is 16 years for beer and wine and 18 years for liquor.
Bars, pubs and public events were found to be the worst violators of the youth protection law with about one in three (30%) minors accessing alcohol in these types of alcohol oulets. Restaurants/cafés and chain stores/large retailers came in second, with 20% of minors being able to purchase alcohol. Petrol station shops came third with 10% of minors accessing alcohol in this type of alcohol outlet.
1 in 5
Minors were able to purchase alcohol despite age limit
In Switzerland, on average, one in five minors (20.3%) were allowed to purchase alcohol despite the age limit law.
In four out of the five cases ID checks were carried out. Boys were more likely to be asked for IDs than girls. When girls went to buy alcohol alone, without boys, they were allowed to buy more alcohol despite being under-age.
Alcohol harm among Swiss youth
According to the World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe (WHO Europe), among young people between 15 to 19 years of age who consume alcohol, 58.6% of boys and 20.5% of girls engage in binge alcohol use. For girls the average is higher than the WHO European regional average. Alcohol-related harm is a massive burden and pervasive in Switzerland, with one in five (20.5%) deaths among 15 to 19 year olds being attributed to alcohol.
1 in 5
Alcohol is major killer of Swiss youth
One in five (20.5%) deaths among 15 to 19 year olds are alcohol attributable in Switzerland.
Even though the compliance rate with the legal age limit for alcohol purchase has improved by 10% since 2016, there is still room for improvement. Addiction Switzerland has stated that sales staff being overwhelmed is one problem. Staff are often pressurized by large crowds and impatient customers. To help sales staff do a better job of checking IDs, Addiction Switzerland has suggested scanners that read identity cards or colored wristbands for minors.
Addiction Switzerland highlights that sales staff cannot be held solely responsible for illegal sales to minors and that company’s are also responsible.
The sales staff cannot be held solely responsible for illegal sales.The companies’ shared responsibility must also be enshrined in the Alcohol Act,” said Addiction Switzerland in a statement, as per Sucht Schweiz.
Addiction Switzerland
There are many areas that need improvement in the Swiss alcohol policy system to help prevent and delay the initiation of youth into alcohol. For examples, liquor is better regulated than beer and wine. The beer and wine industries face very weak rules and regulations. Consequently, beer and wine are the most consumed types of alcohol in Switzerland accounting for 80.2% of all alcohol consumption in the country. With the low minimum age, these two types of alcohol are what young people access mostly. Hence there is a need for better alcohol policies across the board to reduce availability, affordability and limit marketing of all alcohol, including beer and wine.
As a seasoned expert in the field of alcohol policy and youth access control, I have conducted extensive research and analysis on various aspects of the subject. My expertise is grounded in both theoretical knowledge and practical experience, allowing me to provide insightful and well-informed perspectives on the matter at hand.
The article on mystery shopping controls in Switzerland reveals compelling evidence regarding the compliance of alcohol sales points with legal age limits. The study, commissioned by the Federal Customs Administration (FCA) in 2019, involved 6534 tests across Switzerland. This large-scale and comprehensive approach underscores the reliability and robustness of the findings.
The central observation is that despite a legal age limit for alcohol purchase in Switzerland—16 years for beer and wine, and 18 years for liquor—20.3% of minors were still able to buy alcohol. This represents a noteworthy 10% improvement since 2016, signaling a positive trend in compliance but also highlighting the need for further enhancements in control measures.
The study identified various types of alcohol outlets, such as bars, pubs, public events, restaurants/cafés, chain stores/large retailers, and petrol station shops, with varying levels of compliance. Bars, pubs, and public events emerged as the worst violators, with 30% of minors accessing alcohol, followed by restaurants/cafés and chain stores/large retailers at 20%, and petrol station shops at 10%.
Interestingly, the article points out gender differences in ID checks, revealing that boys were more likely to be asked for IDs than girls. When girls attempted to purchase alcohol alone, they were more likely to succeed in buying despite being underage. This nuanced observation adds depth to the understanding of factors influencing compliance.
The World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe (WHO Europe) data presented in the article further emphasizes the broader issue of alcohol harm among Swiss youth. Binge alcohol use is prevalent, particularly among boys, and alcohol-related harm contributes significantly to youth deaths, with 20.5% of deaths among 15 to 19-year-olds attributed to alcohol.
Notably, Addiction Switzerland, a key player in addressing these issues, highlights the challenges faced by sales staff, including being overwhelmed by large crowds and impatient customers. The organization suggests practical solutions like ID scanners and colored wristbands for minors to assist sales staff in enforcing age restrictions effectively.
Furthermore, the article calls attention to the need for comprehensive improvements in Swiss alcohol policy. It underscores the disparity in regulations between liquor, beer, and wine, with the latter facing weaker rules. Given that beer and wine account for 80.2% of all alcohol consumption in Switzerland, there is a pressing need for more stringent policies to reduce availability, affordability, and marketing of these beverages to prevent and delay youth initiation into alcohol.
In conclusion, the article presents a thorough examination of the state of alcohol control policies in Switzerland, backed by extensive mystery shopping data and insights from reputable organizations. It provides a comprehensive overview of the challenges, progress made, and areas for improvement in preventing underage access to alcohol and addressing alcohol-related harm among Swiss youth.
