Should You Take a Stool Softener Or a Laxative If You Can't Poop? (2024)

Find out which you should stock in your medicine cabinet

by
Should You Take a Stool Softener Or a Laxative If You Can't Poop? (1)Should You Take a Stool Softener Or a Laxative If You Can't Poop? (2)

Our product picks are editor-tested, expert-approved. We may earn a commission through links on our site. Why Trust Us?

There's nothing worse than that bloated, tight feeling in your gut when you just can't poop. And when you're struggling to relieve yourself, you'll pretty much try anything to get your system running smoothly again.

So chances are, you've considered a laxative to speed things up. But what's the difference between a stimulant laxative, and a stool softener, which is also marketed to help you go? What's really the best fix for constipation?

Using a stimulant laxative or a stool softener every once and awhile isn't a big deal, as long as you're not depending on them regularly. But which one should you choose to cure your constipation when it does hit?

The right choice depends on whether you’re having a one-time or chronic problem, says gastroenterologist Will Bulsiewicz, MD. If pooping isn’t generally an issue for you and you just need some help for the moment, a stimulant laxative like bisacodyl (Dulcolax) or senna (Sennokot) will do. These work by speeding up and strengthening your colon’s contractions, which aids in pushing your waste out.

You don’t want to use these too often, though, or they could lose their effectiveness. That can create a laxative dependence, leading you to need higher and higher doses in order to poop.

Herbal home remedies for constipation like aloe, cascara, and Smooth Move tea can have the same effect, says Dr. Bulesiewicz.

Stool softeners like docusate (Colace) work by reducing the hardness of stools, which should make them easier to pass. Problem is, they won’t do much if you’re already constipated, since they take three of four days to kick in, he adds. But they can help treat chronic constipation.

If you’re using laxatives more than once a month, Dr. Bulsiewicz recommends talking to a doctor about longer-term solutions like stool softeners. Another remedy might be to take fiber supplements, which adds bulk to your stool to help you go, and an osmotic laxative—which draws water into your intestines to help stool pass easier— like polyethylene glycol (Miralax) or milk of magnesia.

In rare cases, your constipation might not respond to any medication. This could point toward pelvic floor dyssynergia, a condition that stops your anal canal and pelvic muscles from relaxing, says Dr. Bulesiewicz. If you have this condition, you may feel like you have to keep pooping even if you already went, or like you didn't fully poop when you did go. Treating this often requires physical therapy.

How to Tell If Your Poop is Normal:

Should You Take a Stool Softener Or a Laxative If You Can't Poop? (3)

Instead of relying on meds to help you go, though, work on preventing constipation in the first place. The easiest way to do so? Make sure to consume plenty of water and fiber. Exercise can help too, says Bulsiewicz. “When you move, your colon will move as well.”

Related: 5 Ways to Make Yourself Poop

Another trick: Try sitting on the toilet at the same time every day for five minutes. If you can’t poop, just leave. “Having a routine establishes a rhythm that your body can follow,” says Bulsiewicz. “After a few days, your body will amazingly start to recognize what you're trying to accomplish and ramp up to help accommodate your goal.”

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Should You Take a Stool Softener Or a Laxative If You Can't Poop? (2024)

FAQs

Should You Take a Stool Softener Or a Laxative If You Can't Poop? ›

Stool softeners work naturally with the body and are better tolerated with fewer side effects. Stronger laxatives such as stimulant laxatives are more appropriate for more severe symptoms.

Should I take stool softener if I can't poop? ›

You can use a stool softener on a short-term basis to help relieve occasional constipation. Lifestyle factors and pregnancy can both cause constipation. Constipation is also a side effect of some health conditions and medications.

What simple trick empties your bowels immediately? ›

Home remedies include increasing your fiber intake or taking a laxative, using a suppository, or taking a stool softener. Trying out a squat position, doing light exercise, or performing a colonic massage may also help.

When is the best time to take a laxative or stool softener? ›

Stimulant laxatives are usually taken on an empty stomach for rapid effect. Results are slowed if taken with food. Many stimulant laxatives (but not castor oil) are often taken at bedtime to produce results the next morning (although some may require 24 hours or more).

Which works faster stool softener or laxative? ›

Stimulant laxatives, such as Dulcolax and Senna, may take 6–12 hours. Stool softeners, such as Docusate, may take 24–48 hours. Fiber-based laxatives, including Fibercon and Metamucil, can take 12–72 hours.

What is the best thing to use if you can't poop? ›

Laxatives come in several forms: Bulk-forming fiber supplements include calcium polycarbophil (Equilactin, Fibercon), methylcellulose fiber (Citrucel), and psyllium (Fiber-Lax, Konsyl, Metamucil), and wheat dextrin (Benefiber). Unlike other laxatives, you can take these every day. They make the stool bigger and softer.

How can I loosen my bowel blockage at home? ›

5 Home Remedies for Constipation
  1. Eat enough fiber. "The No. 1 thing I recommend is altering your diet," says Dr. Kalakota. ...
  2. Drink plenty of water. ...
  3. Exercise regularly. ...
  4. Use an osmotic laxative to help soften stool. ...
  5. Take a stimulant laxative for quicker relief. ...
  6. The signs it's time to see your doctor about constipation.
Sep 1, 2023

How to trigger a bowel movement? ›

Perform stimulation with your finger every day until you start to have a regular pattern of bowel movements. You can also stimulate bowel movements by using a suppository (glycerin or bisacodyl) or a small enema. Some people find it helpful to drink warm prune juice or fruit nectar.

How to stimulate bowel movement immediately? ›

Try These Tricks for Quick Bowel Movement Stimulation
  1. Drink coffee. Regarding drinks that make you poop, coffee is probably the first that comes to mind. ...
  2. Squat when you poop. ...
  3. Use a fiber supplement. ...
  4. Take a stimulant laxative. ...
  5. Take an osmotic laxative. ...
  6. Take a lubricant laxative. ...
  7. Try a stool softener. ...
  8. Use a suppository.
Aug 2, 2022

What is the 7 second poop method? ›

Crouching on a chair

Sitting a certain way for seven seconds is not proven to help constipation. However, changing your body posture while on the toilet can make things easier. Place your feet on a stool to place your knees higher than your hips.

Is it OK to take a laxative and a stool softener at the same time? ›

Stool Softener with Laxative should cause you to have a bowel movement within 6 to 12 hours. Do not take Stool Softener with Laxative for longer than 7 days in a row, unless your doctor tells you to. Call your doctor if your constipation does not improve or if it gets worse after taking Stool Softener with Laxative.

Is Dulcolax a stool softener or laxative? ›

Dulcolax have a range of laxative products available, including stool softeners that has the #1 doctor recommended stool softener ingredient, docusate.

Can you take a stool softener and laxative in the same day? ›

Can you take stool softeners and laxatives together? In some situations, your healthcare provider may recommend combining a stool softener and laxative. There's an OTC product that combines a stool softener (docusate) and a stimulant laxative (senna).

How do you push out a big hard stool? ›

Follow these 4 simple steps to relieve the symptoms of constipation and pass stool easily.
  1. Keep your knees higher than your hips – a foot stool may help with this.
  2. Lean forwards and put your elbows on your knees.
  3. Bulge out your abdomen.
  4. Straighten your spine.
Feb 10, 2023

What helps constipation within 30 minutes? ›

First, try drinking a cup of warm water, wait 30 minutes, and then gently massage your lower abdomen to try to stimulate the area. If that doesn't seem to help, take a hot shower, with the water concentrated on your lower back.

Why can't I poop even after laxatives? ›

Fecal impaction often occurs in people who have had constipation for a long time and have been using laxatives. The problem is even more likely when the laxatives are suddenly stopped. The muscles of the intestines forget how to move stool or feces on their own.

How do you know when to take a stool softener? ›

A stool softener usually is taken at bedtime. Follow the directions on the package or your prescription label carefully, and ask your doctor or pharmacist to explain any part you do not understand. Take stool softeners exactly as directed.

Should I take stool softener if I haven't pooped in 3 days? ›

The standard time frame for normal bowel movement (BM) frequency ranges from as many as three bowel movements per day to as few as three bowel movements per week. This is a wide range. Our program usually gives patients suffering from constipation a rescue drug to use if no bowel movement has occurred in 3 days' time.

How do you soften an impacted stool quickly? ›

People can buy glycerin and bisacodyl suppositories over the counter, without a prescription. A person will need to insert the suppository into the rectum and wait for it to act. Glycerin appears to work by stimulating an osmotic effect, drawing water into the rectum to soften the mass of stool.

How soon after taking stool softener do you poop? ›

How long do they take to work? You'll usually have a bowel movement after about 12 to 72 hours upon using a stool softener. Don't take stool softeners for more than a week at a time. If you're still having hard stools after a week of using them, contact your healthcare provider.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Errol Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 6179

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Errol Quitzon

Birthday: 1993-04-02

Address: 70604 Haley Lane, Port Weldonside, TN 99233-0942

Phone: +9665282866296

Job: Product Retail Agent

Hobby: Computer programming, Horseback riding, Hooping, Dance, Ice skating, Backpacking, Rafting

Introduction: My name is Errol Quitzon, I am a fair, cute, fancy, clean, attractive, sparkling, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.