If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (2024)

Marshmallows are the perfect accompaniment to pretty much anything—hot chocolate, smores, dessert toppings, baking—but if you’re following a vegan or vegetarian diet, or just trying to be more plant-based, you may be wondering if those fluffy treats fit in with your lifestyle.

After all, marshmallows are usually dairy-free. And if you’re used to avoiding more traditional desserts like pies and brownies for the sake of your health, you may think you’re doing just fine crumbling up a marshmallow (or three) in a cup of vegan hot chocolate. C'mon, who can resist sipping on melty marshmallows? Not me!

But going more plant-based definitely has tons of benefits, like lowering one’s blood pressure and cholesterol. So it would make sense why you’d want to seek out vegan options as much as you can. However, if you’re choosing a traditional marshmallow to satisfy your vegan sweet tooth, you may want to think again. Sadly, most aren't vegan.

When it comes to marshmallows, figuring out whether they're vegan or not really comes down to their ingredient list. Here's what you should know about marshmallows before you go ahead and open another bag.

So, are marshmallows vegan?

Unfortunately, they're not. “Marshmallows are not vegan because they contain gelatin, an animal protein derived from the ligaments, tendons, and skin of animals, such as cows and pigs,” explains registered dietician Grace Pascale. Gelatin doesn’t taste like meat at all, since it’s created by boiling down the various animal body parts with water, but it’s used in marshmallows in order to create that gooey, glutinous center that melts in your mouth.

“Gelatin and related products are also commonly found in puddings, ice cream, candy, certain yogurts, and even things like shampoo and cosmetics, in order to add that texture,” adds Pascale.

If you want a vegan option, you have to stay away from items that contain this ingredient. But don’t stress. There are several vegan substitutes that use other ingredients to create that same yummy texture.

Some amazing, RD-approved vegan options to try:

1. Dandies Vegan Marshmallows

Dandies Vegan Marshmallows

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (1)

Super gooey and perfect to place into an oat milk hot chocolate, Dandies Vegan Marshmallows were created when its founder, whose son has been vegan for years, couldn’t find any vegan marshmallows at the store. Talk about a father-son bond.

2. Trader Joe’s Vegan Marshmallows

You can always rely on good ol’ TJs: These gluten-free, vegan marshmallows are clutch for baking.

3. Goodland Farms Large Vegan Marshmallows

Goodland Farms Large Vegan Marshmallows

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (3)

Goodland Farms Large Vegan Marshmallows

For a fresh, cruelty-free s'more, these extra-large vegan marshmallows toast up so good that you'll forget non-vegan options even exist.

4. Smucker’s Vegan Marshmallow Topping

Smuckers Marshmallow Topping

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (4)

This "accidentally vegan" topping by Smuckers is a crowd favorite, and can be dolloped on desserts or beverages for a creamy flavor.

5. Freedom Confectionery Mini Pink and White Mallows

Freedom Mallows Freedom Confectionery - Mini Pink & White Vanilla Mallows

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (5)

Freedom Mallows Freedom Confectionery - Mini Pink & White Vanilla Mallows

Now 44% Off

The U.K. brand has both vanilla and strawberry flavors, and is even soy-free—proving that vegan marshmallows can, in fact, be pretty damn healthy.

Can you make your own vegan marshmallows?

Yes! You just have to replace the gelatin with a vegan-friendly substitute. “Gelatin is essentially cooked collagen, so collagen and collagen-derived products and supplements are not vegan-friendly either,” explains Pascale.

Instead, try some agar-agar powder. “Agar-agar is a flavorless gelling agent derived from cooked seaweed, which many vegans will substitute in place of gelatin in homemade marshmallow or Jell-O recipes," says Pascale.

One thing to note: When you’re cooking with ingredients such as agar-agar powder, the vegan-friendly alternative can be subbed into recipes for gelatin in equal amounts," Pascale explains.

LIVING JIN Agar Agar Powder

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (6)

LIVING JIN Agar Agar Powder

Now 17% Off

So basically, even if you find a recipe online that isn’t vegan, you can substitute the gelatin or collagen with agar-agar or another thickening agent like carrageenan, which is derived from seaweed, and can be found online on Amazon.

If you’re looking for a specific, tasty vegan recipe, Pascale loves this one from the blog The Hidden Veggies.

Basically, you mix a combo of ingredients and acids, boil water and sugar to mix, and then bake. It’s relatively easy, and even though some of the ingredients might be new to you, they’re all easy to find in the spice section of the grocery aisle.

Now, all you need to do is get some (vegan!) graham crackers to really enjoy your newfound, plant-based marshmallows.

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (7)

Nikhita Mahtani

Nikhita Mahtani is an NYC-based freelance journalist covering primarily health and design. She graduated with an M.A in Magazine Journalism from New York University and loves to debunk popular health myths. Her idea of wellness includes a sweaty spin class, wine with loved ones, and experimenting with new recipes in the kitchen.

If You’re Wondering Whether Marshmallows Are Vegan, The Answer Is Yes And No (2024)

FAQs

Is marshmallow vegan or not? ›

By the 20th century, however, the gooey mallow plant had been replaced with animal-based products like egg whites and gelatin, making most commercially available marshmallows distinctly non-vegan. This holds for both individual marshmallows and whipped marshmallow creams popular in desserts like fudge.

What marshmallow ingredients are not vegan? ›

So, are marshmallows vegan? Unfortunately, they're not. “Marshmallows are not vegan because they contain gelatin, an animal protein derived from the ligaments, tendons, and skin of animals, such as cows and pigs,” explains registered dietician Grace Pascale.

How do you answer the question why are you vegan? ›

So the bottom line to the number one reason why I am vegan: I love animals and I do not have any desire to eat something with a life of its own to live. And with this answer, I feel justified.

Are Skittles vegan? ›

With that in mind, the simple answer is: yes. Skittles Classic Fruits are suitable for vegans. Though the bag only brands them as 'Suitable For Vegetarians', classic Skittles do have a vegan friendly status as they contain no animal products.

Are Kraft Jet puffed marshmallows vegan? ›

No, they are not. Jet puffed marshmallows are one of the more popular marshmallows in North America, but they contain gelatin, an animal product, making them not suitable for vegans or vegetarians.

Is peanut butter vegan? ›

The bottom line. Most types of peanut butter are free of animal products and can be enjoyed as part of a vegan diet. However, some varieties are made in facilities that also process animal products or contain refined sugar that was produced using bone char or non-vegan ingredients like honey or fish oil.

What candy is vegan? ›

Fortunately, loads of candies are vegan, so we can indulge our cravings (mostly) guilt-free. Most dark chocolate is vegan, as are popular sweet treats such as Smarties (known as Rockets in Canada), Oreos, Airheads, Jujubes, and Swedish Fish (some Swedish Fish contain beeswax, so be sure to check the label).

Is jello vegan? ›

The rumors are true. Marshmallows, Jell-O, gummy bears… although they seemingly bear no resemblance to animals (well, other than the gummy bears), these foods often aren't vegetarian. That's because they contain gelatin, a substance used to create the “fun,” gooey, chewy textures we expect from these foods.

Are Oreos vegan? ›

In short, the vast majority of Oreos are vegan and do not contain any animal ingredients (not even milk!). These include: Classic Oreos, Golden Oreos, Double Stuff, and Chocolate Cream Oreos. The only Oreos which are not suitable for vegans are the Peanut Butter flavoured biscuits which contain milk.

Are pretzels vegan? ›

At their core, yes, pretzels are technically vegan. But you should still be careful about checking labels, and asking the right questions before you buy the salty snack. “Many store-bought brands of both hard and soft pretzels do not contain eggs or milk, so they would be considered vegan,” says Palmer.

Are peeps vegan? ›

Peeps are not vegan or vegetarian, according to the company that makes them. “Our marshmallow candies are not vegan because they contain pork-derived gelatin,” says a statement from Just Born, the manufacturer of Peeps. The company claims the pork is essential for the “great eating experience” it creates.

What are 3 reasons people go vegan? ›

Some research has linked that there are certain health benefits to vegan diets with lower blood pressure and cholesterol, and lower rates of heart disease, type 2 diabetes and some types of cancer. Going vegan is a great opportunity to learn more about nutrition and cooking, and improve your diet.

What made you a vegan? ›

Many abstain from animal products because they find factory farming cruel and inhumane. As well as the slaughtering of animals for meat, many vegans are concerned that egg-laying chickens and dairy cows can lead unnecessarily miserable and short lives.

What is vegan answer? ›

Vegans do not eat animals or animal-based products like meat, fish, seafood, eggs, honey and dairy products such as cheese. For many vegans, living a committed vegan lifestyle means not wearing clothes made from animal skins and avoiding any products which have been tested on animals.

Can vegans eat marshmallow fluff? ›

While traditionally made marshmallow have gelatin in them which make them not vegan, marshmallow fluff does not. However, marshmallow fluff does contain egg whites. That ingredient makes them not safe for anyone on a vegan or plant based diet, but also someone with egg allergies.

What is a vegan substitute for gelatin? ›

Plant-based gelatin alternatives

Cornstarch and agar agar (an algae-based product found in the seaweed section) have both been used to successfully replicate these tricky textures. Like gelatin, both cornstarch and agar agar are activated when combined with a hot liquid.

Do all marshmallows contain gelatin? ›

The traditional marshmallow recipe uses powdered marshmallow root, but most commercially manufactured marshmallows instead use gelatin in their manufacture. Vegans and vegetarians avoid gelatin, but there are versions which use a substitute non-animal gelling agent such as agar.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Greg O'Connell

Last Updated:

Views: 5904

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg O'Connell

Birthday: 1992-01-10

Address: Suite 517 2436 Jefferey Pass, Shanitaside, UT 27519

Phone: +2614651609714

Job: Education Developer

Hobby: Cooking, Gambling, Pottery, Shooting, Baseball, Singing, Snowboarding

Introduction: My name is Greg O'Connell, I am a delightful, colorful, talented, kind, lively, modern, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.