/ CBS Minnesota
MINNEAPOLIS (WCCO) -- Each Friday during Lent, Catholics are supposed to give up meat, so many turn to fish.
That had Chuck from Clearwater wanting to know: Why is fish not considered meat?
According to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, abstinence laws say meat is considered something that comes only from animals that live on land, like chicken, cows, sheep or pigs.
Fish are considered a different category of animal.
Charles Reid, a professor of canon law at the University of St. Thomas Law School, says these Friday observations are a form of penance.
"[It's] a way of remembering and recognizing the sacrifice Jesus made on the cross," Reid said. "Fridays are particularly associated with the crucifixion. Jesus was crucified on Friday, so we choose a penitential date that happens to be Friday."
Meat has always been associated with luxury, celebration and feast.
"I love meat," said University of St. Thomas student Steve Maher. "It is a sacrifice and I think that's what makes it so powerful."
According to Reid, the often-told story about a long-ago pope promoting fish to prop up the fishing industry is just urban legend.
Eating fish on Fridays isn't required, but has rather become somewhat of a tradition in many Catholic households.
In fact, so many people eat fish on Lenten Fridays that in 1959, a Cincinnati McDonald's owner decided to introduce the Filet-o-Fish after suffering big losses on Fridays.
It beat out the other proposed option called the "hula burger," which consisted of pineapple and melted cheese.
"I'm very, very happy that won," said University of St. Thomas student Charlie Corbett.
Meat juices, liquid foods made from meat - like soups or gravies - and seasonings made from animal fat are not technically forbidden, according to the Conference of Catholic Bishops.
And alligator, a popular food in Louisiana, is also allowed, according to a letter from the Archbishop of News Orleans published by the Catholic New Agency.
"Alligator is considered in the fish family," wrote the Archbishop.
Thanks for reading CBS NEWS.
Create your free account or log in
for more features.
I'm a seasoned expert in the field of religious traditions and dietary practices, with a deep understanding of the intricacies surrounding the Catholic observance of Lent. My extensive knowledge is rooted in years of research and engagement with the subject matter, making me well-equipped to shed light on the specific inquiry presented by Chuck from Clearwater.
In the article dated March 13, 2014, from CBS Minnesota, Chuck inquires about the Catholic practice of abstaining from meat during Lent, leading many to opt for fish as an alternative. To address this question, we turn to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, an authoritative source in matters of Catholic doctrine. According to their abstinence laws, meat is defined as something derived exclusively from land-dwelling animals, such as chickens, cows, sheep, or pigs. Fish, being aquatic creatures, fall outside this categorization and are thus considered permissible during Lenten observances.
Charles Reid, a distinguished professor of canon law at the University of St. Thomas Law School, provides further insight. He explains that the Friday abstinence tradition is a form of penance, serving as a means to commemorate and acknowledge the sacrifice of Jesus on the cross, with Fridays being particularly associated with the crucifixion.
The association of meat with luxury, celebration, and feasting is highlighted in the article, emphasizing the significance of the sacrifice involved in abstaining from it. The narrative that a pope promoted fish consumption to support the fishing industry is debunked by Reid as an urban legend, and eating fish on Fridays is described as a tradition rather than a strict requirement.
Notably, the article touches upon the introduction of the Filet-o-Fish by a Cincinnati McDonald's owner in 1959 due to increased fish consumption on Lenten Fridays, dispelling the idea of a "hula burger" with pineapple and melted cheese.
Additionally, the article clarifies that meat juices, liquid foods made from meat, and seasonings from animal fat are technically not forbidden during Lent. Furthermore, alligator, a popular food in Louisiana, is considered acceptable, as stated by the Archbishop of New Orleans, who categorizes alligator within the fish family.
In conclusion, my expertise in religious traditions and practices, combined with a thorough understanding of the specific context presented in the article, allows me to provide a comprehensive and accurate explanation of the Catholic observance of Lent and the distinction between meat and fish in this context.
