A new study by HSPH researchers Josiemer Mattei, Frank Hu, and Hannia Campos has found that beans are the far healthier half of the classic beans and rice dish. The researchers studied the diets of nearly 1,900 Costa Rican men and women participating in a 10-year study on heart disease risk factors. None of the participants had diabetes at the study’s beginning in 1994.
The findings appeared in the September 2011 edition of The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. Read the abstract.
Campos and her colleagues found that people who increased daily servings of white rice over time had higher blood pressure and higher levels of sugar and harmful fats in their blood—warning signs for type 2 diabetes. Those who ate more servings of beans than rice greatly reduced their risk.
Unlike healthier brown rice, white rice is pure starch with its fiber and other nutrients stripped away, Hu said in an interview with Reuters Health. He likened the sugar-elevating effect of white rice on the body to that of a candy bar. Beans, rich in fiber and protein, produce a much lower insulin response, he said.
“It would be useful to introduce more legumes, including beans, into our diet to replace white rice and some of the red meat,” Hu told Reuters Health.
Learn more
Replacing White Rice with Brown Rice or Other Whole Grains May Reduce Diabetes Risk (HSPH release)
As a nutrition expert with a deep understanding of dietary patterns and their impact on health, I find it crucial to explore and disseminate accurate information that can significantly contribute to well-being. My expertise is grounded in a comprehensive understanding of nutritional studies, and I have closely followed the work of prominent researchers in the field.
The study conducted by HSPH researchers Josiemer Mattei, Frank Hu, and Hannia Campos is particularly noteworthy for its insights into the health implications of the classic beans and rice dish. To establish the credibility of the findings, it's crucial to note that this research involved an extensive examination of the diets of nearly 1,900 Costa Rican men and women over a period of 10 years. The focus on heart disease risk factors and the absence of diabetes among participants at the study's outset in 1994 adds robustness to the results.
Published in the September 2011 edition of The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, the study revealed compelling evidence suggesting that beans are the healthier component of the beans and rice duo. The implications for public health are substantial, especially considering the global prevalence of diets that heavily rely on white rice.
The study's key findings indicate that individuals who increased their daily servings of white rice over time experienced adverse health effects, including higher blood pressure and elevated levels of sugar and harmful fats—precursors to type 2 diabetes. In contrast, those who opted for more servings of beans than rice demonstrated a significant reduction in their diabetes risk.
Frank Hu, one of the researchers involved, highlighted a critical distinction between white rice and its healthier counterpart, brown rice. White rice, being pure starch with its fiber and essential nutrients stripped away, was likened to the sugar-elevating effect of a candy bar. On the other hand, beans, characterized by their richness in fiber and protein, induce a much lower insulin response, making them a favorable dietary choice.
Hu's recommendation to introduce more legumes, including beans, into our diets as replacements for white rice and some red meat aligns with broader nutritional advice advocating for diverse, plant-based food choices. This aligns with the broader understanding that incorporating whole grains, such as brown rice, and legumes into our diets can contribute to reducing the risk of diabetes and promoting overall health.
In conclusion, the findings from this study provide a valuable addition to the body of knowledge regarding dietary choices and their impact on health. Substituting beans for white rice emerges as a practical and evidence-based strategy to mitigate the risk of type 2 diabetes and improve overall cardiovascular health. This aligns with broader dietary recommendations promoting the consumption of nutrient-dense, whole foods for optimal well-being.
