Different Kinds of Icing: A Comprehensive Guide (2024)

Don’t know your ganache from your fudge buttercream? Hazy on the difference between glaze and royal icing? Don’t worry. This guide to different kinds of icing, glazes and frostings has you covered, providing education on all sorts of toppings and fillings that take the cake.

From rich, chocolatey ganache to pretty and sophisticated fondant, this visual guide explains the differences between the many different types of icing, as well as exploring some of the best ways in which they can be used in your cake decorating. Bookmark this page as a reference for future cake decorating projects!

1. Buttercreams

One of the most common and versatile cake toppings and fillings, buttercream actually covers a fairly wide array of different cake toppings.The basic composition of buttercream is fat (often, as the name might imply, butter, but not always) and sugar. However, the ingredients and methods employed can vary quite greatly. Here are some of the most common types of buttercream.

American-style buttercream

From Zoë François’s

This is probably what most people think of as a classic birthday cake frosting. Made primarily from butter and confectioners’ sugar, this buttercream can be tinted or flavored in a number of different ways.

Crusting buttercream

From Shannon Bond’s

Crusting buttercream is a variant of American-style buttercream thatis frequently made with part shortening and a little more sugar than usual so that it is soft when made, but sets as it firms. This type of buttercream is especially popular for cakes featuring piping, as the designs are a bit sturdier against elements such as heat or possible jostling.

Flour buttercream

Sometimes called boiled milk frosting, cooked milk buttercream or ermine buttercream, flour buttercream is unique because it’s made by boiling a mixture of flour, sugar, and milk until it thickens to a pudding-like consistency. It’s then cooled and beaten with butter and flavorings to make a silky, delicious buttercream that visually resembles an American buttercream.

Cream cheese frosting

Cream cheese frosting is a type of American-style buttercream thatemploys cream cheese instead of or in addition to butter (or other fat). It is a common frosting to use on top of carrot cake, Hummingbird cake, and red velvet cake.

Meringue buttercream(s)

From Erica O’Brien’s Better Buttercream

Meringue buttercreams prominently feature egg whites.The most popular meringue buttercreams are Swiss buttercream (egg whites and sugar cooked and then whipped with butter), Italian meringue buttercream (where boiled sugar is slowly poured into an egg white meringue mixture then beaten with butter) and French meringue buttercream (where uncooked egg whites are mixed with sugar and cream of tartar).

Custard buttercream

This buttercream is sort of like a cross between boiled milk buttercream and French buttercream. A pastry cream is combined with butter and/or confectioners’ sugar to a spreading consistency. This type of buttercream is best for a filling, but when enough sugar is added, it can be piped.

French buttercream

Not to be confused with French meringue buttercream, this rich cake topping and filling is made with hot sugar combined with egg yolks rather than whites. Since the eggs are not cooked, they can be pasteurized before making this type of buttercream to reduce the chance of foodborne illness.

Fudge buttercream

There is a particular sub-set of American-style buttercreams that contain chocolate(either melted chocolate or a cocoa powder mixture), which is then incorporated with abutter and sugar mixture. Not to be confused with fudge icing, which is boiled, this is a buttercream that starts with either melted chocolate or cocoa powder combined with butter, which is then cooled and whipped with sugar and flavorings to a fluffy consistency.

Rolled buttercream

Often made with shortening, this is a buttercream with much higher amount of sugar, giving it a clay-like consistency that can be rolled. It is not quite as flexible as fondant but can be used for some of the sameapplications.

2. Caramel icing

From Carole Bloom’s

The process of making this icing issimilar to the process of making candy. A brown sugar and milk mixture is boiled, and combined with butter and sugar until it reaches a spreadable consistency. This icing is best applied to a cake right after it is made, as it will set firm.

3. Ganache

Is ganache a cake topping? Pastry filling? Glaze? Chocolate filling? The answer to all of the aboveis yes.One of the most common types of ganache is made using approximately equal weights in cream and chocolate. It is made bybringing cream to a simmer, then pouring it on top of chopped chocolate, then mixing until smooth. The mixture starts out quite liquid, but firms as it sets. It can be used as a drizzle, or as it becomes thicker as it cools, it can be used to cover an entire cake.Once firm, it can be used as a filling for chocolates.

4. Glaze

Confectioners’ sugar glaze

From Jenny McCoy’s Icing on the Cake: The Ultimate Frosting Toolkit

This simple glaze is made using confectioners’ sugar with a small amount of liquid added (often milk or water). It can be quite liquid or thicker, like a syrup, depending on the ratio of sugar to liquid.It is often used as a drizzle(for instance, on top of a quick bread) or as an all-over translucent topping(for instance, glazed doughnuts).

Chocolate glaze

A chocolate glaze is a pourable chocolate topping. It can range from translucent to opaque, but it is typically thin enough that it can be poured. A ganache could be used as a chocolate glaze, but a number of varieties exist.

5. Gum paste

Gum paste is a pliable dough which is often used for cake decorating. It is made usingegg whites, confectioners’ sugar, and shortening. It can be rolled quite thin and is ideal for creating hand-modeled flowers or other intricate decorations. While fondant will remain soft, gum paste dries quite hard and is better suited for decoration on a cake than for, say, covering an entire cake.

6. Fondant

Rolled fondant

From Rachael Teufel’s

Generally when it comes to cake decorating, rolled fondant is the type in question. Rolled fondant is a pliable, dough-like icing that is popular for use on occasion cakes. It is made of sugar, water, gelatin, and food-grade glycerine. Its smooth appearance gives cakes a polished look, and rolled fondant is also flexible and workable enough to mold into shapes, which is very effective for decorating cakes.

Poured fondant

A variation of fondant that remains at a pourable consistency and has a glossy finish once dried. It is often used on top of cakes or pastries.

7. Fudge icing

From Alice Medrich’s Decadent Chocolate Cakes

Milk or cream, cocoa powder, sugar, and other flavorings are brought to a boil and cooked until they thicken to make this icing. While it will be pourable/spreadable at first, it will firm to a fudge-like consistency as it cools, so it is best used right away.This is similar to caramel icing but made using cocoa powder instead of brown sugar.

8. Marzipan

This mixture of almond paste, sugar, and flavorings is an elegant addition to cakes.Thick and pliable, it can be molded into cake decorations, rolled and used like fondant, or used as a cake layer or filling.

9. Mexican paste

This paste is somewhat similarto fondant but firmer and with a glossier finish. This is primarily used for creating sculpted or cut out elements for a cake, but can be difficult to work with if trying to cover an entire cake.

10. Modeling chocolate

From Rachael Teufel’s Mastering in Minutes: Modeling Chocolate

This is a chocolate paste made by melting chocolate and combining it with corn syrup or simple syrup and then kneaded until it reaches a stiff, pliable consistency. Used like clay, this modeling chocolate can be molded into a variety of shapes that are not as easily performed with the softer fondant. Modeling chocolate can be made from white, dark, semi-sweet, or milk chocolate. White chocolate is the easiest type to tint in colors.

11. Pastillage

Similar to fondant, but without any of the ingredients to make it soft. This will set hard (not firm) and is best used for sculptural elements on cakes. It is often used in highly stylized works of cake art such as the ones featured in Craftsy’s course High-Fashion Heels.

12. Royal icing

This simple mixture of egg whites, confectioners’ sugar, and often a touch of lemon has a consistency thatcan be piped, but it dries hard. It is often used to create ornate cookie decorations. It can also be used to pre-make flowers or other cake decorations to be used at a later date, and it’s also what you use to make homemade sprinkles.

13. Simple syrup

Simple syrup is made by combining equal parts sugar and water, sometimes with flavorings, and then heating the mixture until it reduces to a syrup-like consistency. This can be used as a glaze, or it can be used to keep cake layers moist.

15. Whipped cream frosting

Whipped cream can be used as a frosting or filling for cakes. Typically, the type used for cakes is a stabilized whipped cream, which is enforced with marshmallow, butter, or gelatin for a more firm texture that won’t melt as easily.

What is your favoritecake topping?

Comments