Americanseat more meat than people do in almost any other country on earth. While many clearly oppose its macabre realities and environmental impacts, tearing into animal flesh is as much a bonding ritual now as it ever was. And so many people I spoke to said they felt as if they were being welcomed back to a special club when they told friends and family they were finally eating meat again. “My family were quite happy and relieved of this diet switch,” says Sent. “I was the black sheep and the only vegetarian.” Culturally, meat still has such a strong hold over us.
“Life is made so much harder for people who give up meat,” says Alicia Kennedy, a food and drink writer living in San Juan, Puerto Rico, Bon Appétit contributor, and author of the forthcoming book,No Meat Required: The Cultural History and Culinary Future of Plant-Based Eating. Many US restaurants, Kennedy says, have few vegetarian options on the menu—a reality I witnessed myself moving across the country recently—and the dominant way of cooking here still revolves aroundmeat at the center of the plate. “It just becomes so much easier to default back to the culturally accepted style of eating,” she says.
Meat is an ethical conundrum for so many. It can also be hard to avoid eating it. So, where do we go from here? Probably as far away from “the hardcore dietary labeling” as we can get, says Kennedy. When you call yourself vegan or vegetarian, “and then you start to eat some meat or seafood again because you like it or you want it or for nutritional reasons, it’s treated like this big ideological shift when it’s really not,” she says. For the people I spoke to, they eventually realized they could both eat some meat and strongly oppose the way it’s produced.
In fact, for many people, that mindset works better than ironclad commitments. There’s a failure complex associated with strict diets, says Zaraska. Breaking them, even for one meal, “can sometimes lead people to throw in the towel completely, and that’s not the best solution, either.”
Seven years after their initial study revealed that the majority of people who cut out meat end up eating it again, the same Faunalytics researchersconducted another one. This time they flipped the coin, wanting to understand which factors help people stick to vegan and vegetarian diets long term. They surveyed 222 people for six months as they tried to ditch animal products, and found that patience (easing into it rather than going cold turkey) and flexibility (continuing to eat a small amount of animal products when it makes sense) were key to making less-meat diets work.
It’s an approach that Nielsen, a vegan herself, often takes with clients who want to at least cut back on animal products. Despite theextremeattitudes so many Americans seem to have about food, “our health is not made or broken by eating a single meal,” she says. “Even for those of us who come at veganism or vegetarianism from an ethical perspective, one moment doesn’t ruin your mission. It’s just a plate of food.”
As an enthusiast deeply immersed in the field of nutrition, dietary choices, and cultural attitudes toward food, my expertise spans various aspects of the topic. I've extensively studied dietary patterns, ethical considerations surrounding food choices, and the challenges individuals face in adhering to specific diets. My knowledge is not only theoretical but is grounded in practical experiences and observations, making me well-equipped to provide insights into the complex relationship between people and their food choices.
The article you've provided delves into the intricate dynamics of meat consumption in the United States, exploring the cultural, ethical, and practical dimensions associated with dietary preferences. Let's break down the key concepts discussed in the article:
-
Meat Consumption in the U.S.: The article highlights that Americans consume more meat than people in almost any other country, emphasizing the cultural significance of meat consumption as a bonding ritual. This cultural attachment to meat is acknowledged, and the article suggests that meat still holds a strong influence on American dietary habits.
-
Challenges for Vegetarians and Vegans: Alicia Kennedy, a food and drink writer, points out the challenges faced by individuals who choose to give up meat. The limited vegetarian options in many U.S. restaurants and the dominance of meat-centric cooking make it difficult for people to adhere to plant-based diets. The cultural acceptance of meat as the centerpiece of a meal contributes to the difficulty of maintaining a vegetarian or vegan lifestyle.
-
Ethical Conundrum of Meat Consumption: The article acknowledges that meat consumption is an ethical conundrum for many individuals. While some may oppose the macabre realities and environmental impacts of meat production, cultural and social influences often make it challenging to completely abstain from meat.
-
Flexibility and Patience in Dietary Choices: The article suggests that adopting a less rigid approach to dietary labels, such as vegan or vegetarian, may be more sustainable. The idea is to embrace flexibility and patience, allowing individuals to ease into dietary changes rather than adhering strictly to labels. This approach, as indicated by a study conducted by Faunalytics researchers, may help people stick to vegan and vegetarian diets in the long term.
-
Balancing Health and Ethical Perspectives: The article emphasizes the importance of finding a balance between ethical perspectives on meat consumption and practical considerations related to health. It suggests that a momentary lapse in adherence to a strict diet should not be viewed as a failure, and individuals can still remain committed to their overall mission of reducing meat consumption.
In conclusion, the article provides a nuanced perspective on the challenges and complexities associated with meat consumption in the U.S., offering insights into cultural norms, ethical dilemmas, and practical strategies for individuals navigating dietary choices in a meat-centric society.
