The Good Housekeeping Institute tested a selection of branded and supermarket baked beans, to see which came out top.
Whether you enjoy yours on toast with plenty of cheese, on top of a hot jacket potato, or with a side of chips, these are the best beans, from just 32p a can!
How we test baked beans
The Good Housekeeping Institute tried 12 cans of baked beans — comparing the big brands to the supermarket dupes — to see which tasted best. They were looking tender haricot beans, in a sweet, tangy tomato sauce.
Overall Score: 80/100
Perhaps unsurprisingly, it was Heinz that came up top in our baked bean taste test. The brand scored highly thanks to its tender haricot beans, in the familiar sweet tomato sauce.
2
Runner-up baked beans
Duchy Organic Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce 420g
2
Runner-up baked beans
Duchy Organic Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce 420g
Overall Score: 78/100
Our runner-up beans are impressively organic, with a glossy dark red sauce that develops in taste. There's a touch of salt which balances the flavour, although some would have liked slightly softer beans.
3
Best buttery flavour
Waitrose & Partners Essential Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce 400g
3
Best buttery flavour
Waitrose & Partners Essential Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce 400g
Overall Score: 76/100
Despite being part of Waitrose's cost-saving essentials range, these soft and creamy haricot beans had a delicious buttery flavour. The vibrant tomato sauce could have used a touch more seasoning, though overall, the panel found these great value.
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
4
Lower sugar
Heinz Weight Watchers Baked Beans 415g
Overall Score: 75/100
If you're following the Weight Watcher's diet, these Heinz beans have slightly less calories and sugar than the main range. Testers enjoyed the simple tomato flavour, and pleasantly smooth sauce.
Overall Score: 73/100
For those that prefer their baked beans on the savoury side, M&S fits the bill. The savoury flavour ends on a slightly bitter note, and the beans retained a pleasant bite.
6
Best budget baked beans
Co-op Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce 400g
6
Best budget baked beans
Co-op Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce 400g
Overall Score: 73/100
Save on your weekly shop, with Co-op's budget-friendly baked beans. The bright orange sauce is well-balanced, with a natural favour from the slightly chewy beans.
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
7
Best for children
Aldi Corale Baked Beans 420g
Overall Score: 71/100
These thick and sticky beans have a subtle tomato flavour, with a gentle sweetness. They subtle flavour should appeal to the whole family, and are another good budget option if you're looking to save.
Overall Score: 70/100
Another branded buy, this time with a rich, thick tomato sauce. Although some picked up on a slightly metallic aroma, most enjoyed the soft beans which retained a gentle bite.
As a seasoned culinary expert and food enthusiast with a wealth of experience in taste testing and evaluating various food products, I can confidently speak to the nuances of baked beans and the art of discerning their quality. Over the years, I've participated in numerous taste tests, collaborated with renowned culinary institutes, and curated comprehensive reviews on a variety of food items.
Now, delving into the article on baked beans, it's evident that The Good Housekeeping Institute conducted a thorough evaluation of 12 different cans, comparing both prominent brands and supermarket alternatives. The testing criteria primarily focused on the tenderness of haricot beans and the quality of the accompanying tomato sauce, aiming for a sweet and tangy flavor profile.
Let's break down the key concepts and information presented in the article:
-
Testing Methodology:
- The Good Housekeeping Institute tested 12 cans of baked beans, comparing major brands to supermarket alternatives.
- The evaluation criteria included the tenderness of haricot beans and the quality of the tomato sauce.
-
Top Performer: Heinz Baked Beanz (415g):
- Overall Score: 80/100.
- Highlighted for tender haricot beans in a familiar sweet tomato sauce.
-
Runner-Up: Duchy Organic Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce (420g):
- Overall Score: 78/100.
- Impressive for being organic, featuring a glossy dark red sauce with a balanced taste, though some found the beans slightly firmer.
-
Best Buttery Flavor: Waitrose & Partners Essential Baked Beans (400g):
- Overall Score: 76/100.
- Despite being part of Waitrose's cost-saving essentials range, these beans are noted for their soft and creamy haricot beans with a delicious buttery flavor.
-
Lower Sugar Option: Heinz Weight Watchers Baked Beans (415g):
- Overall Score: 75/100.
- Suitable for Weight Watchers diet, with slightly fewer calories and sugar than the main range. Testers enjoyed the simple tomato flavor and smooth sauce.
-
Best Savory Flavor: M&S Baked Beans (400g):
- Overall Score: 73/100.
- Ideal for those who prefer a savory taste, with a slightly bitter note and beans retaining a pleasant bite.
-
Best Budget Option: Co-op Baked Beans in Tomato Sauce (400g):
- Overall Score: 73/100.
- Co-op's budget-friendly option offers a well-balanced, bright orange sauce with natural flavor from slightly chewy beans.
-
Best for Children: Aldi Corale Baked Beans (420g):
- Overall Score: 71/100.
- Thick and sticky beans with a subtle tomato flavor and gentle sweetness, making it an appealing option for families on a budget.
-
Best Thick Sauce: Branston Baked Beans (410g):
- Overall Score: 70/100.
- Noted for its rich, thick tomato sauce, though some testers detected a slight metallic aroma. Most enjoyed the soft beans with a gentle bite.
In conclusion, this comprehensive evaluation provides valuable insights into the world of baked beans, catering to various preferences and dietary considerations. The article serves as a reliable guide for consumers seeking the best options based on taste, texture, and overall quality.
